| Posted: Wednesday, August 19th, 2009 | Comments (0)
Ed in the Sand
By: Brandon Dutcher
Ninety-one years ago, Nicholas II of Russia was taken down to the basement and shot.
I don't think he believed it would ever come to that. After all, wasn't he a benevolent tsar, a father to his people? The House of Romanov had ruled for three centuries. Surely his people would always be loyal.
But times were changing in turn-of-the-century Russia, and the increasingly unpopular autocrat failed to grasp the seriousness of it all. He was “insulating himself from unpleasant facts,” University of Oklahoma historian J. Rufus Fears recently told me.
“History shows us that institutions collapse,” Dr. Fears says, “when the people they are supposed to serve lose confidence in them.”
In a survey conducted last year by Education Next and the Program on Education Policy and Governance at Harvard University, Americans were asked to grade the nation's public schools. More Americans gave the schools a D or an F than gave them an A or a B.
Here at home, a survey of 1,200 likely Oklahoma voters (margin of error of +/- 3 percent) asked the decidedly unloaded question: “If it were your decision and you could select any type of school, what type of school would you select in order to obtain the best education for your child?”
Seventeen percent said they would choose a regular public school. Eighty-three percent said they would choose something else.
That's not a misprint. Only 17 percent said they would choose a regular public school. The rest would choose a private school (41 percent), home school (19 percent), charter school (17 percent), or virtual school (6 percent).
And what was Big Ed's reaction to this overwhelming vote of no-confidence?
One union official mumbled something about the survey's methodology, but of course didn't produce any specific criticisms.
Another comforted herself with the assurance that “our parents do have a choice, and they overwhelmingly choose public schools.” Which calls to mind the question posed by education reporter Mike Antonucci: “If the government, under the force of law, takes money from my paycheck every month to supply me and every other citizen with a Yugo, and I choose not to spend additional personal income on a Chevy, am I 'choosing' the Yugo?”
It would be tough to refute a survey conducted by a firm whose polls have been used by MSNBC, Time, and Newsweek, and have been cited as some of the nation's most accurate by National Journal's “Hotline.” Realizing that, state Sen. Jay Paul Gumm (D-Durant) acknowledged the “opinion polls suggesting Oklahomans are losing confidence in public schools,” but explained: “No wonder, given the relentless attacks on public schools repeatedly launched” by critics.
Did you catch that? People are losing confidence not because they are discerning consumers who are wise enough to know what they know. It's not because the product is defective; it's because weary taxpayers have the temerity to point out that the product is defective. The 400-pound woman has heart disease not because she inhales Big Macs and bon bons, but because her doctor has the audacity to diagnose her problem and shoot straight with her.
Some public-school enthusiasts are so insulated from unpleasant facts that they actually sing hosannas. An enraptured Sen. Gumm recently wrote of “the glory of public education.” State Rep. Neil Brannon (D-Arkoma) said on the House floor that public education is the “salvation” of our country. State Rep. Scott Inman (D-Del City) averred that “our public school system is the greatest institution in the world.”
Of course it is. And the Romanov dynasty will last forever.
At 83-17, I don't think I'd go the head-in-the-sand route. Big Ed needs to face reality. Because you know, institutions can collapse when people lose confidence in them.
Other Stories From Summer 2009 Issue
Do Treaties Supersede the United States Constitution?
Robert Godwin
This article is the result of HCR 1033 authored by state Representative Sally Kern which passed the...
True Economic Development
Jason Murphey
If you have read my articles in the past, you know that I am a strong opponent of special perks and...
The Nanny State of the Future
Randy Brogdon
How far will Obamacare intrude into our lives? Often overlooked among the myriad of costs and...
Ed in the Sand
Brandon Dutcher
Ninety-one years ago, Nicholas II of Russia was taken down to the basement and shot.
I don't th...
State’s Rights on Steroids
Richard Engle
The United States is in the midst of a constitutional crisis. President Barak Obama is eager to...
Will a Heavy Federal Boot Cause Okies to Say No More?
Charlie Meadows
An important word picture is that of a person's boot on the neck of another person who is down and...
Voter Vault 3: This Could Be the Most Important Tool the Republican Party Has in its Arsenal!
Rick Moore
When I first received the call to the Oklahoma Republican Party State Committee meeting for July, I...
Just One Vote
Steve Byas
There was a popular love song that went something like, “Just one look, that’s all it took, Just...
The Federal Page
Theodore King
From apathy to dependence, our next destination will be bondage.
On April 29th, the U.S. House v...
In The Mail
Constitution Staff
THIRD PARTY NEEDED
In the 2009 Spring edition of the Oklahoma Constitution, Richard Engle stated...
Constitution Tidbits
Constitution Staff
SETBACK FOR INITIATIVE RIGHTS
Oklahomans for Initiative Rights, which organized a 70 city state...
Earmarks, The Real Problem
Constitution Staff
With the recent campaign waged by Sen. John McCain for president (I know that is a stretch to say...
Oklahoma to Apply for High Speed Rail
Constitution Staff
Oklahoma transportation officials plan to seek federal stimulus funds to make the state part of a...
Oklahoma Tea Party
Constitution Staff
Nearly 5,000 concerned citizens descended on the south steps of the Oklahoma Capitol in one of...
Voter ID Measure to be on Statewide Ballot
Constitution Staff
Following a gubernatorial veto of similar legislation, it will be left to Oklahoma voters to decide...
In The News
Constitution Staff
Candidates for State Offices
In the non-presidential election years, the governor's seat, a host of secondary statewide...
Izzy Lyman
Contrasts: Candidates Costello, Reese, Coates, and Clem on Illegal Immigration
The geographic contrasts between Arizona and Oklahoma are sharp, yet the public concerns about...
Constitution Staff
GOP Expected to Maintain Control of Legislature
Even before the first vote is cast in the 2010 elections, Republicans are already assured of...
Constitution Staff
The Race for Governor
Since 1950, the pattern has been clear: whichever party wins the presidency usually loses the...
Constitution Staff
Candidates for Congress
The U.S. Congress is composed of two chambers. Senators serve six-year terms with only a third of...
Constitution Columnists
Robert Godwin
The Seventeenth Amendment Buried the Republic
The 17th Amendment buried our republican form of government in 1913, with the original...
Charlie Meadows
OCPAC 2010 Good and Bad Legislators
For over 10 years, the voting members of the Oklahoma Conservative Political Action Committee ...
Rick Moore
ATTENTION CANDIDATES: If You Are Serious about Winning, Sign the Taxpayer Protection Pledge
Fiscal restraint, fiscal responsibility, and expense leadership continue to take center stage during...
This Week's Oklahoma Conservative PAC Report
09/01/2010 08:17 AM
Members and friends of the Oklahoma Conservative Political Action
Committee (OCPAC)
The extra e-mail this week is about a very important issue. While
OCPAC is mostly pointed toward state issues, we are a statewide
organization and we do care about our congressional delegation. More
than likely our 4 congressional seats currently held by Republicans ...Continued Inside...
This Latest Tweets From The Conservatives At #OKTCOT
09/06/2010 07:13 AM
NewsOK Tropical Storm Hermine gaining strength in Gulf: BY THE ASSOCIATED PRESSMIAMI ? Tropica... http://bit.ly/al2tet #oktcot #tcot #tlot
OKgrassroots@twitter.com (OKgrassroots)
09/06/2010 02:46 AM
#tcot #oktcot FBI's inside man says he's on outside now - Democrat Corruption - http://is.gd/eXglp
OklahomaForums@twitter.com (Mike)
09/06/2010 02:42 AM
#tcot #oktcot Latest Rand Paul Poll Brings Utter Silence from Liberal Blogs - http://is.gd/eXg5x
OklahomaForums@twitter.com (Mike)
09/06/2010 02:40 AM
#tcot #oktcot Top 10 Boneheaded Parenting Trends From the Left - http://is.gd/eXfSU
OklahomaForums@twitter.com (Mike)
09/06/2010 02:35 AM
#tcot #oktcot The Path to Victory in Washington - http://is.gd/eXfCN
OklahomaForums@twitter.com (Mike)
09/06/2010 02:33 AM
#tcot #oktcot Obama spending Labor Day with real thugs - http://is.gd/eXfun
OklahomaForums@twitter.com (Mike)
09/06/2010 02:30 AM
#tcot #oktcot Bidengate! - http://is.gd/eXfin
OklahomaForums@twitter.com (Mike)
09/06/2010 02:25 AM
#tcot #oktcot GOP raids Democrats' donor list - http://is.gd/eXf0L
OklahomaForums@twitter.com (Mike)
09/06/2010 02:23 AM
#tcot #oktcot Reject the Freeze - http://is.gd/eXeRe
OklahomaForums@twitter.com (Mike)
09/06/2010 02:20 AM
#tcot #oktcot Get Involved - Take America Back! - http://is.gd/eXeB8
OklahomaForums@twitter.com (Mike)
© 2001 - 2009 The Oklahoma Constitution, all rights reserved.
Contact the Oklahoma Constitution by calling 405-366-1125 or emailing okconsti@aol.com
Content Management System (CMS) provided by WebTeks2010.com - Guthrie, Oklahoma.



