Conservative Index Add

Saturday, July 20th, 2019Last Update: Tuesday, May 7th, 2019 11:03:32 AM

Gerhart Conviction Overturned

By: Constitution Staff

A couple of years ago, Oklahoma Constitution editor Steve Byas wrote in his column, concerning the conviction of Al Gerhart on blackmail charges involving an email sent to then-State Senator Cliff Branan, the following words: "If we truly believe in the concept of liberty, we believe in it for those we do not agree with, those we dislike, and those who are quite unpopular."

Now, the Oklahoma Court of Criminal Appeals, in a 3-2 decision, has overturned the blackmail conviction of Gerhart, opining, "Legislators and other public officials expect to receive vehement, caustic, and sometimes unpleasantly sharp attacks from the citizens they represent. That is the nature of elected public office."

The circumstances which led Oklahoma County District Attorney David Prater to file blackmail charges against Sooner Tea Party leader Al Gerhart involved Gerhart's email demanding Branan hear a bill in his committee. Branan was chairman of a committee of the Senate, and had decided to not hear a bill which proposed to prohibit any local government in the state from adopting or implementing policy recommendations established by the United Nations' Agenda 21 sustainable development action plan. The bill had passed the House of Representatives by a veto-proof margin, but Branan simply refused to even hear the bill in his committee.

This caused Gerhart to send Branan the email which led to blackmail charges. "Get that bill heard or I will make sure you regret not doing it. I will make you the laughingstock of the Senate if I don't hear that this bill be heard and passed. We will dig into your past, your family, your associates, and once we start on you there will be no end to it."

The Court commented, "We find the Appellant's email threatening to investigate the past of the Senator and his family and associates if the Senator did not get the bill a hearing and pass it out of committee as Appellant wished is the kind of vehement, caustic and unpleasantly sharp political speech protected by the First Amendment. Appellant sought to bring about political change. While his method of doing so may be seen as bombastic and extreme with unfortunate and unnecessary references to the Senator's family and associates, this type of political hyperbole does not take the communication out of the protections of the First Amendment. As the Supreme Court said in Alvarez, "[o]ne of the costs of the First Amendment is that it protects the speech we detest as well as the speech we embrace."

Interestingly, the Court compared Gerhart's method not much different "in reality" from "the corporate lobbyist who subtly infers the loss of campaign contributions and support if a bill is not heard or passed. While the finesse is greater, the political pressure is the same."

The decision did not address the constitutionality of the blackmail statute. It simply said that Gerhart had not violated it. "The First Amendment does not require that constituents be rational, reasonable, kind or even polite in their communications with elected representatives," the Court said.

"Appellant's email does not amount to blackmail under Oklahoma law. Rather, it represents legitimate political activity. We must never allow the Oklahoma blackmail statute to become a sword used to suppress mere political speech."

In addressing the blackmail statute, the Court argued, "Appellant's email did not urge or compel the Senator to violate the law or commit an unlawful act, nor was it sent with the intent to compel the Senator to violate the law. The email was sent with the intent to convince the Senator to change his mind on a political issue."

And the Court held that such an email did not constitute blackmail. "Speech does not lose its protected character . . . simply because it may embarrass others or coerce them into action."

Other Stories From Fall 2015 Issue

The Boren Identity: Surprised by Someone I Completely Disagree

Andrew K. Boyle
It is easy to complain about government. Our system of self government is well suited for the cranky...

The Federal Page (Fall 2015)

Theodore King
Planned ParenthoodIn March 2012, pro-life activist and founder of Operation Rescue, Randall Terr...

Did the Grinch Steal the Monument?

Richard Engle
On September 11, 2015 an Oklahoma County District Court ordered that the Ten Commandments monument...

Stopping President Obamas Federally Funded Curriculum and the Expansion of Government Control

Linda Murphy
President Obama said, If you like your school with local control you can keep your school with...

Oklahoma Personal Asset Protection Act SB 838

Kaye Beach
State Senator Kyle Loveless (R-Oklahoma City) is the author of Senate Bill 838, the Personal Asset...

Four of a Kind

Steve Byas
President Calvin Coolidge once said, It is better to kill a bad bill, than to pass a good one....

Growing a Backbone

John Michener
The human backbone begins developing during the first few weeks of an embryos existence in the...

The Senate Transparency Conundrum

Jason Murphey
Regular readers of the states appropriations bill were greeted by something new as they opened...

Thomas Sowell Interview

Brandon Dutcher
In an excellent interview which recently appeared in The Wall Street Journal, the economist Thomas...

Tidbits for Fall 2015

Constitution Staff
Jari Askins Takes New PostGovernor Mary Fallin announced September 18 that Jari Askins, speci...

(Letter to the Editor)

Constitution Staff
State Judicial MisconductMuch has been said and written, in many locations, about the judicia...

Special Elections for Vacancies in Legislature

Constitution Staff
One vacant legislative seat was recently filled and candidates have filed for the special election...

Cathy Costello Highlights 2015 Defenders of Liberty Awards

Constitution Staff
Cathy Costello, widow of the late Labor Commissioner Mark Costello, accepted the Samuel Adams...

Gerhart Conviction Overturned

Constitution Staff
A couple of years ago, Oklahoma Constitution editor Steve Byas wrote in his column, concerning the...

Pam Pollard Elected Republican State Chairman

Constitution Staff
Pam Pollard Elected Republican State Chairman...

In The News

Constitution Staff

Medicaid Initiative Petition Filed
A filing was made at the Oklahoma Secretary of State office on April 19 for proposed State Question...

Constitution Staff

State Election Board Conducts Voter List Maintenance
The State Election Board completed its statutorily-mandated, biennial voter list maintenance on...

Constitution Staff

Bills Make Their Way Through Oklahoma Legislature
With the close of the legislative session approaching at the end of May, various bills are being...

Constitution Staff

Gov. Stitt Establishes Cabinet
On January 24, Gov. Kevin Stitt issued his first executive order since becoming governor. The...

Constitution Staff

Oklahoma Republicans Elect Leaders and Adopt Platform
On April 6, nearly 1,000 delegates attended the Oklahoma Republican State Convention held at the...

Constitution Columnists

Richard Engle

No More Mr. GOP
Many years ago when I was still young enough to be a Young Republican, I served as State Chair of...

John Michener

The Duty to Abolish Abortion: We are Without Excuse
The movement to abolish abortion has finally reached critical mass. Enough concerned and educated...

Tim Bakamjian

Stitts Strong Start
In his January 14th inaugural address, Governor Kevin Stitt outlined a clear set of goals for his...

© 2001 - 2009 The Oklahoma Constitution, all rights reserved.
Contact the Oklahoma Constitution by calling 405-366-1125 or emailing
Content Management System (CMS) provided by WebTeks CMS.