Conservative Index Add
pagetitle

Sunday, April 21st, 2019Last Update: Thursday, January 31st, 2019 08:02:19 PM

The Medicaid Mess and How to Deal with it

By: Tim Bakamjian

Medicaid is a means-tested entitlement program that is overseen by the federal government, but is run by the states. States receive one dollar in federal funding for every dollar they spend. It was created in 1965 as one of President Lyndon Johnson’s many Great Society programs. It provides basic health care coverage to children, adults with dependent children, disabled, blind and elderly Americans whose income falls below certain levels. More than 70 million Americans, including about one million Oklahomans, have Medicaid, making it the largest health insurer in the country and in the state.

Costs and enrollment in Medicaid on both a federal and state level have far exceeded projections. In Oklahoma, enrollment has more than doubled in the last 20 years. As of 2017, Oklahoma’s share of the costs reached $2.1billion annually, a 194.1% increase from the $714 million spent in 2003.

In 2010, the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act (a/k/a Obamacare) became law. The legislation mandated states to extend Medicaid to adults with no dependents whose income fell below 138% of the federal poverty level. The federal government agreed to cover all the costs for newly eligible enrollees for three years, and soon after cover all but 10% of their health care expenses. Any state that didn’t comply would lose all federal reimbursement for Medicaid funding.

In 2012, the U.S. Supreme Court ruled that the federal government couldn’t force states to expand Medicaid. However, thirty-three states and the District of Columbia have done so. With three red states – Utah, Idaho and Nebraska – passing ballot initiatives last November, Oklahoma is now one of only fourteen states that have not expanded Medicaid.

Most likely, outside left-leaning groups will try to bypass the Legislature and take Medicaid expansion straight to the voters in 2020. They’ll deploy millions of dollars and hire an army of advocates to win passage next year.

If they’re successful, Oklahomans would soon discover what most states are finding out: Medicaid expansion is an unmitigated disaster. For example:

1. Every state that has expanded Medicaid under the ACA has seen enrollments far exceed estimates, usually by double digits. In Colorado, maximum projected enrollment was 187,000 but ballooned to 446,000 in 2016. In Kentucky, enrollment went from 188,000 to 439,000, a 134% increase. Nationwide, states expected 5.5 million new recipients but got 11.5 million out of the first 24 states that expanded.

2. Due to low compensation rates, a high percentage of doctors don’t accept Medicaid patients, and that gets worse each year. Many patients wait months to receive specialized care. Currently, about 650,000 people nationwide are on waiting lists for coverage. In 2017, only 53% of doctors in 15 large metropolitan areas took Medicaid patients. Access to expensive drugs is often limited. In other words, care is being increasingly rationed in states that expanded Medicaid under Obamacare.

3. Health outcomes under Medicaid have been no better than people without insurance. A two-year study from Oregon showed no improvement over the uninsured, with results worse than those with private coverage. Another study found that patients undergoing surgery for colon cancer were more likely to die from complications than those without coverage. And another finding found that in-hospital mortality rates were higher for surgical patients with Medicaid

than those lacking coverage. Overall more than $500 billion dollars are being spent nationwide on a program that not only often fails to improve the health of its enrollees, but frequently undermines it.

4. Medicaid, like entitlements such as Medicare and Social Security, is on a crash course with fiscal realty. Medicaid expansion only makes that worse, as costs have far exceeded projection in every state (30) that has reported data..

California’s expansion has run 222% over budget, causing a $14.7 billion deficit. Oregon is $2 billion in the red from its 128% deficit. West Virginia went 46% over budget in its first year alone, costing them an additional $198 million. Eight states, including neighboring Arkansas and Colorado, have been forced to raise taxes to fund their Medicaid expansion. All this despite the federal government paying most of the added expense.

Governor Kevin Stitt was wise to campaign against Medicaid expansion and has shown no signs of wavering from that position. Fortunately, alternatives exist that will enable Oklahomans to receive quality health care without busting our state budget and affecting monies allocated for education, infrastructure, public safety and other statewide needs. For instance:

1. Rigorous audits of Medicaid funds, to focus tax dollars on those most in need. Audits have saved Massachusetts $250 million so far, and Louisiana expects up to $85 million in savings. Oklahoma’s version is the recently passed HB 1270, which should help ensure money goes to those most eligible.

2. Enact minimum work requirements for able-bodied recipients.

3. Create incentives for patients to transition to the private insurance market by utilizing Health Savings Accounts (HSAs) toward Direct Primary Care Services (DPCS). For a low monthly fee, beneficiaries would receive affordable care and cut out insurance middlemen.

4. Reform occupational licensing laws so more health professionals can perform a wider range of tasks.

5. Form compacts with other states so individual or group insurance can be bought across state lines. The increased competition would lower prices and improve quality.

6. Bundle those with the greatest healthcare costs into state-run insurance pools, which in turn would provide those in better health with premium relief.

7. Make sure beneficiaries pay at least a portion of their healthcare expenses. Eliminating, or at least reducing, subsidies to the sick will strengthen their will to live a healthy life and to work for a living.

In his upbeat inaugural address, Governor Stitt preached greater accountability, efficiency and modernization in how the state meets the needs of Oklahomans. How his administration deals with Medicaid and the forces promoting its expansion will be a major test of his ambitious goals.

Tim Bakamjian is an independent real estate broker and investor living in Tulsa. He holds a bachelor’s degree in political science from Kenyon College in Ohio and a bachelor’s in journalism from the University of Tulsa. He’s married with one grown child. Political and economic issues have been a life-long interest. He may be contacted at: tbakamjian@gmail.com

About Tim Bakamjian

Tim Bakamjian is an independent real estate broker and investor living in Tulsa. He holds a bachelors degree in political science from Kenyon College in Ohio and a bachelors in journalism from the University of Tulsa. Hes married with one grown child. Political and economic issues have been a life-long interest. He may be contacted at: tbakamjian@gmail.com

Other Articles By Tim Bakamjian

The Medicaid Mess and How to Deal with it

Medicaid is a means-tested entitlement program that is overseen by the federal government, but is...

Stitt vs. Edmondson: A Comparison of Candidates

Oklahomas two main gubernatorial candidates are sharply different in background and approach to...

Other Constitution Columnists

David Deming

A Tale of Two Professors
In the Fall 2018 issue of the Oklahoma Constitution, I related the persecution of OU law professor...

Jason Murphey

Stopping the Revolving Door
It was quite the surreal moment in the Oklahoma House of Representatives! As the 2018 legislative...

Julie Wilkinson

How I Got In. How I Left.
Back in 1984, left a dysfunctional relationship with my boyfriend in Florida, and decided to move...

Steve Byas

Legislature: Rescind the Con-Con Call
Legislature: Rescind the Con-Con CallJames Madison, the father of the Constitution, said he feared...

Steve Byas

Career Politician
Far too often, political campaigns discuss matters that are really not all that important. Rather...

Tim Bakamjian

The Medicaid Mess and How to Deal with it
Medicaid is a means-tested entitlement program that is overseen by the federal government, but is...

Theodore King

The Federal Page for Winter 2019
Congresswoman Kendra HornI suppose I should offer congratulations to Congreswoman Kendra Horn on her...

Richard Engle

Abolition Making Victims into Criminals
In the recent GOP gubernatorial primary a premature retiree from the State House, Dan Fisher, ran a...

Linda Murphy

Oklahoma Education and Workforce Development
Oklahoma state government is in transition to new leadership with Gov. Kevin Stitt, Lt. Gov. Matt...

John Michener

Why Kill Bills?
Grassroots activists around the state support bills based on principle. We believe there is a right...

Charlie Meadows

What Is Wrong With Our Media?
This article will evaluate TV, local talk radio and the Oklahoman regarding the quality of...

In The News

Constitution Staff

Voters Reject Four of Five State Questions
Six statewide ballot measures were certified for the 2018 elections in Oklahoma. One measure, the...

Constitution Staff

All Judges Survive Retention Ballot
On November 6, Oklahoma voters retained four Supreme Court justices, three Court of Criminal Appeals...

Constitution Staff

Democrats Flip Oklahoma Congressional Seat
The big news coming out of the Oklahoma congressional elections was the flipping of the Fifth...

Constitution Staff

Republicans Sweep Statewide Secondary Offices
In addition to the governors office, a host of secondary statewide offices, and one seat for the...

Constitution Staff

Governor Kevin Stitt
On January 14, J. Kevin Stitt was inaugurated as the 28th governor of the State of Oklahoma. He...

Constitution Columnists

David Deming

A Tale of Two Professors
In the Fall 2018 issue of the Oklahoma Constitution, I related the persecution of OU law professor...

Jason Murphey

Stopping the Revolving Door
It was quite the surreal moment in the Oklahoma House of Representatives! As the 2018 legislative...

Julie Wilkinson

How I Got In. How I Left.
Back in 1984, left a dysfunctional relationship with my boyfriend in Florida, and decided to move...

© 2001 - 2009 The Oklahoma Constitution, all rights reserved.
Contact the Oklahoma Constitution by calling 405-366-1125 or emailing okconsti@aol.com
Content Management System (CMS) provided by WebTeks CMS.